Justice Elissa Neville overturns cancellation of teacher’s licence over messages with 13-year-old girl
The Manitoba judge ruled Education Minister Tracy Schmidt failed to justify ending Robert Hrabluk’s teaching career, sending the case back for reconsideration.

A Manitoba judge has overturned the education minister’s decision to permanently revoke the teaching certificate of a longtime music teacher who exchanged private social-media messages with a 13-year-old female student.
Court of King’s Bench Justice Elissa Neville ruled Education Minister Tracy Schmidt’s reasons for cancelling Robert Hrabluk’s certificate were “simply not good enough.”
Hrabluk taught guitar and band in the Louis Riel School Division for 23 years. A school division investigation began in July 2024 after he disclosed that a parent had confronted him about messages exchanged with the Grade 8 student.
The girl reportedly followed Hrabluk online and initiated the conversation. Their intermittent communication continued for approximately four months before her parent discovered it.
The exact messages were not published in the 36-page ruling. Neville noted they were not sexualized, while Schmidt described the communications as “persistent, secretive and obviously inappropriate.”
The school division initially suspended Hrabluk without pay for five days, reassigned him to another school, required additional training and placed him under “intense supervision.” It concluded that he had demonstrated remorse and could be trusted with students.
Child and Family Services classified the matter as a valid incident but found no abuse.
A provincial Certificate Review Committee later recommended permanently cancelling Hrabluk’s licence, finding that he had violated professional boundaries and school policies.
Schmidt’s office first sent Hrabluk a signed decision imposing a one-year suspension. Thirty minutes later, officials told him to disregard it because it had been sent in error. The following day, Schmidt cancelled his certificate entirely.
“I am not prepared to tolerate online grooming behaviour from a certified Manitoba teacher, even on a one time basis,” Schmidt wrote.
Neville found the cancellation decision largely copied the suspension letter despite imposing a dramatically harsher penalty. The minister also failed to explain how the communications constituted grooming or why Hrabluk’s record, training, remorse and future risk did not justify a lesser sanction.
The judge stressed that she was not deciding what Hrabluk’s punishment should be or clearing him of misconduct. She ruled that a career-ending penalty required reasons supported by the evidence.
Neville quashed the cancellation and returned the case to Schmidt for a new decision. The minister remains free to cancel Hrabluk’s certificate again but must properly justify the result.
Justice Watch
Justice Watch is a Rebel News project exposing the judges, rulings, and court decisions reshaping Canada from the bench. We track activist judgments, soft-on-crime rulings, and judicial appointments, along with their real-world impact on victims, families, freedom, and public safety, using public records, court decisions, news reports, and unapologetic commentary.
Visit Justice Watch